Electronic Arts was facing a great deal of competition for its Madden NFL games from Sega and other video game makers, and was forced to lower its price. So it purchased an exclusive license to make games using NFL logos, essentially creating a monopoly, since few would spend development money to create a game without the ability to sell the realism of an NFL experience. This may or may not be actionable under antitrust laws, but it did result in a class action. The resulting settlement has gotten much criticism from the technology and gaming press for letting EA keep its exclusive license, but the settlement is even worse than they report. When all is said and done from the claims process, consumers will likely end up with under a million dollars, while the attorneys are requesting $9.2 million for themselves. Even if we were to assume the entire $27 million settlement fund is "class recovery" (and how can we when over 95% of it is going to people who aren't class members?), the $9.2 million is over 34% of the fund, several million dollars higher than the Ninth Circuit benchmark. As a member of the class who got his inspiration for my current gig when I objected to a similarly bad video game class action settlement, how could I ignore such unfairness? The Center for Class Action Fairness filed an objection Monday.
Pecover v. Electronic Arts class action settlement objection
- CCAF objects to Easy Saver coupon settlement
- Blessing v. Sirius XM Second Circuit argument tomorrow morning
- Toyota settles shareholder suit over sudden acceleration hysteria
- Cert grant in American Express v. Italian Colors
- Briefing complete in In re Online DVD Antitrust Lit. (9th Cir.)
- Amgen, Johnson & Johnson, Bernstein Litowitz, and the fraud on the market theory
- HP Inkjet oral argument
- Opening brief in Kitagawa v. Apple (9th Cir.)
- Wyly v. Weiss: speaking of lack of marginal deterrence value of civil litigation...
- Dennings v. Clearwire Corporation class action settlement
- Why is there a single settlement class in the $2.43 billion Bank of America settlement?
- Whirlpool v. Glazer
- More on Texas anti-coupon law
- Antitrust and technology in the 1990s
Center for Legal Policy at the