Subscribe Subscribe   Find us on Twitter Follow POL on Twitter  



Yuba City pays Danegeld

| No Comments

"Yuba City pays man not to file any disability suits." [Sacramento Bee; related earlier on POL]

Interestingly, CBS coverage (via Fed Soc) calls the suits "frivolous." I dislike the term because of the confusion it engenders. George Louie's ADA suits, which impose more social costs than social benefits, are certainly "frivolous" in the colloquial sense. But if a layperson complains about "frivolous lawsuits," they will be told by tort reform opponents that there are already laws for punishing lawyers who bring "frivolous lawsuits." This is technically true, but entirely equivocation: the law defines "frivolous lawsuit" so narrowly that a case like Stella Liebeck's, where she sues for injuries from spilling coffee on herself, is not "frivolous" in the technical legal sense, because she persuaded a judge to ignore the law and allow the suit to proceed.

I prefer the term "meritless lawsuits" (for lawsuits without legal or without factual merit, though plaintiffs may prevail in some of them because of errors in the legal system) or the broader term "socially wasteful lawsuits" (which includes lawsuits where plaintiffs are entitled to prevail because of decisions by courts or legislatures to incur substantial net social cost to society at large).

Leave a comment

Once submitted, the comment will first be reviewed by our editors and is not guaranteed to be published. Point of Law editors reserve the right to edit, delete, move, or mark as spam any and all comments. They also have the right to block access to any one or group from commenting or from the entire blog. A comment which does not add to the conversation, runs of on an inappropriate tangent, or kills the conversation may be edited, moved, or deleted.

The views and opinions of those providing comments are those of the author of the comment alone, and even if allowed onto the site do not reflect the opinions of Point of Law bloggers or the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research or any employee thereof. Comments submitted to Point of Law are the sole responsibility of their authors, and the author will take full responsibility for the comment, including any asserted liability for defamation or any other cause of action, and neither the Manhattan Institute nor its insurance carriers will assume responsibility for the comment merely because the Institute has provided the forum for its posting.

Related Entries:



Rafael Mangual
Project Manager,
Legal Policy

Manhattan Institute


Published by the Manhattan Institute

The Manhattan Insitute's Center for Legal Policy.