PointofLaw.com
 Subscribe Subscribe   Find us on Twitter Follow POL on Twitter  
   
 
   

 

 

FHFA warns against using eminent domain to address mortgage crisis

| 1 Comment


Jarrett Dieterle
Legal Intern, Manhattan Institute's Center for Legal Policy

In a recent Featured Column on POL, Richard Epstein criticized a proposal put forth by law professor Richard Hockett that would allow local governments to address the mortgage crisis via eminent domain. Epstein explained the proposal as follows:

Now we have another equally bad proposal to intervene in the mortgage market. Recent pieces in the New York Times by Joe Nocera and Robert Schiller, have eagerly embraced an idea put forward by Cornell University Law Professor Robert C. Hockett. In an incredibly tedious and self-important article, Hockett suggests that local government agencies use eminent domain power to condemn mortgages that are underwater but not yet in default--at reduced prices (what Nocera calls "steep but fair discount")--and then let some municipal authority refinance the loans and resell them in bundles for a profit to the agencies in question. Naturally such a scheme would require a middle man, and a fat fee. Mortgage Resolution Partners (whom Hockett advises) is happy to play that role.

Earlier this week, Hockett's eminent domain proposal found another skeptic. Edward DeMarco, chief regulator for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, issued a public notice under the auspices of the FHFA expressing concerns about using eminent domain to condemn underwater mortgages:

FHFA has significant concerns about the use of eminent domain to revise existing financial contracts and the alteration of the value of Enterprise or Bank securities holdings. In the case of the Enterprises, resulting losses from such a program would represent a cost ultimately borne by taxpayers.

Among other things, the FHFA is worried about the constitutionality of the proposal, its possible effects on holders of existing securities and contracts, and the potential cost to taxpayers. The FHFA even warned that it might take action against local governments that institute such proposals:

FHFA has determined that action may be necessary on its part as conservator for the Enterprises and as regulator for the Banks to avoid a risk to safe and sound operations and to avoid taxpayer expense.

The FHFA's public notice included an invitation for public commentary on the matter up until September 7th as the agency "moves forward with its deliberations on appropriate action." In the meantime, taxpayers have a well-placed ally in the fight against this "fancy con game."

1 Comment

The nation is affected by home loans that are underwater, where the proprietors owe more than the property is worth. It's approximated that up to one-third of houses are. However, a California mortgage company has the novel notion of using eminent domain to “condemn” the home loans and force a refinance.

Leave a comment

Once submitted, the comment will first be reviewed by our editors and is not guaranteed to be published. Point of Law editors reserve the right to edit, delete, move, or mark as spam any and all comments. They also have the right to block access to any one or group from commenting or from the entire blog. A comment which does not add to the conversation, runs of on an inappropriate tangent, or kills the conversation may be edited, moved, or deleted.

The views and opinions of those providing comments are those of the author of the comment alone, and even if allowed onto the site do not reflect the opinions of Point of Law bloggers or the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research or any employee thereof. Comments submitted to Point of Law are the sole responsibility of their authors, and the author will take full responsibility for the comment, including any asserted liability for defamation or any other cause of action, and neither the Manhattan Institute nor its insurance carriers will assume responsibility for the comment merely because the Institute has provided the forum for its posting.

Related Entries:

 

 


Isaac Gorodetski
Project Manager,
Center for Legal Policy at the
Manhattan Institute
igorodetski@manhattan-institute.org

Katherine Lazarski
Press Officer,
Manhattan Institute
klazarski@manhattan-institute.org

 

Published by the Manhattan Institute

The Manhattan Insitute's Center for Legal Policy.