PointofLaw.com
 Subscribe Subscribe   Find us on Twitter Follow POL on Twitter  
   
 
   

 

 

"Citogenesis"



Today's xkcd discusses the problem of "citogenesis," the problem where bogus information is inserted into Wikipedia, sloppy writers copy their information from Wikipedia, and then a cite to the sloppy writer is added to Wikipedia, making the bogus information "true." I've seen this first-hand.

Inspired by Amity Shlaes's The Forgotten Man, I was reading up on the American Liberty League, a bipartisan organization opposed to the New Deal's infringements on economic liberty; interested in conspiracy theories, I wrote in 2009 about the so-called Business Plot, an alleged planned coup in 1934.

I was curious whether there was any basis for the 21st-century riff on the 1930s conspiracy theory that Prescott Bush, the father and grandfather of presidents, was a part of the American Liberty League and the Business Plot. (The claim was that FDR cut a secret deal, undocumented by any history books, to avoid prosecuting the conspirators in exchange for their support of the New Deal; the claim is plainly bogus, as the American Liberty League continued to oppose the New Deal and went on to successfully strike down the National Industrial Recovery Act a year later.)

The only academic source for Bush's role in the American Liberty League I could find was in a Charles Beard book, with a 2008 introduction written by University of Massachusetts history professor Clyde Barrow. This introduction was almost word-for-word taken from an inaccurate 2007 version of a Wikipedia article written by a conspiracy theorist. I asked Professor Barrow where he got the source for his claims, and why the Wikipedia article was so similar to his later-written introduction, and got no response.

Moral is: don't trust Wikipedia. Or liberal history professors.

 

 


Isaac Gorodetski
Project Manager,
Center for Legal Policy at the
Manhattan Institute
igorodetski@manhattan-institute.org

Katherine Lazarski
Press Officer,
Manhattan Institute
klazarski@manhattan-institute.org

 

Published by the Manhattan Institute

The Manhattan Insitute's Center for Legal Policy.