Kentucky state law bans lobbyists from giving to state legislative campaigns, but the state legislative ethics commission decided that an incident involving a Kentucky senator's aides asking lobbyists for money was an innocent mistake that did not warrant discipline. Attorney John M. Berry publicly criticized the commission for their inaction and that merited a full-fledged 15-month investigation and a warning letter from the state bar association. Berry sued in federal court, arguing that the disciplinary rule was facially unconstitutional because it, inter alia, barred "reckless truths," true statements made with reckless disregard for their truth or falsity; the district court held the rule was not subject to a facial challenge, and that Rooker-Feldman barred a collateral attack on the actual discipline itself. [AP/Kentucky.com]
Berry v. Schmidt
- In the Matter of McCutcheon: The Merits of Campaign-Finance "Aggregation"
- Teen Sexting, Youthful Mistake or Felony?
- $42M verdict reinstated in Kentucky fen-phen fraud
- Ninth Circuit refuses to extend Caronia
- Ahmed v. McDonald's
- More on Caronia
- United States v. Caronia
- Michael Mann sues conservative critics for libel
- The libertarian case for Romney
- "The terrorists' veto"
- Around the web, September 16
- Around the web, September 4
- Lemus v. H&R Block
- Update: Apple iPhone 4 bumper class action settlement
- Abusive trustees above the law in California?