Patent defendants would find themselves involuntarily checked into the plaintiff-friendly Eastern District of Texas, and they couldn't check out. Now (per The Recorder) the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has "ruled that Eastern District Judge John Ward 'clearly abused' his discretion when he denied TS Tech Co.'s motion to transfer its patent fight with Lear Corp. to a more convenient venue in Ohio." On top of the Fifth Circuit's recent Volkswagen case, it's pretty clear that appellate judges are growing impatient with the district's notorious reputation as a forum-shopping destination.
Escaping East Texas's patent Roach Motel?
Related Entries:
- "When Lawyers Become Trolls"
- Madison County's controversial asbestos litigation system under fire yet again
- Alex Tabarrok on medical patents
- Preempro jackpot justice verdicts in Philadelphia
- Study: patent trolls cost at least $500 billion
- "Something intrinsically unusual is occurring in Philadelphia"
- Around the web, September 20
- Multi-defendant patent suits
- More on the Eastern District of Texas
- "Patent company has big case, no office"
- Around the web, August 25
- Why is the Eastern District of Texas home to so many patent trolls?
- "This American Life" on patent trolls and the patent arms race
- Dilbert on the patent arms race
- Loser pays in action: punishment for a patent troll
![]() |
| Isaac Gorodetski Project Manager, Center for Legal Policy at the Manhattan Institute igorodetski@manhattan-institute.org |
![]() |
| Bridget Carroll Press Officer, Manhattan Institute bcarroll@manhattan-institute.org |



