Utah: "A judge on Friday struck down a law enabling the state to fatten its general fund by taking half of all punitive damage awards above $20,000 in civil lawsuits." "Split-award" laws on punitive damages, which came to national note recently when Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger proposed one in California (see Overlawyered, Jun. 2), are in effect in eight states. They have come under challenge from trial lawyers in several of those states (supposedly as a "taking" of plaintiffs' property -- Richard Epstein, call your office), but only the Colorado courts have struck them down. The latest ruling is by no means the last word in Utah, not only because of the chance of appeal, but also because it "applies to the law as it read before lawmakers amended it earlier this year. The amendment eliminated dire tax consequences for plaintiffs, but also made the law less vulnerable to attack by patterning it after a Georgia statute that has withstood legal challenges." (Elizabeth Neff, "Damage-awards law tossed", Salt Lake Tribune, Jun. 12).
Utah court tosses "split-award" law
- Does medical malpractice liability lead to better quality health care?
- Missouri Supreme Court strikes down noneconomic damage caps in med mal cases
- Spirited med-mal debate complete!
- New Featured Discussion: MI and Cato scholars debate med-mal
- Tennessee Legislature sends tort reform package to governor
- What interests the Canadians at the trial lawyers convention
- Legislatures cap damages: Minorities, union workers hardest hit
- Prairie dog bite: $328,370
- New Zealand's unique injury compensation system
- Klick and Sharkey, "What Drives the Passage of Damage Caps?"
- Yoo-hoo! ABA Journal!
- Bigger jury verdicts during the holiday season?
- Grace & Leverty on tort reform and insurance rates, cont'd
- "Putting a stop to tort windfalls"
- Litigation earmark for black-farmers suit