A small victory for the Center for Class Action Fairness LLC won a small victory in In re HP Laserjet Printer Litigation, when the court reduced the fee request for a worthless coupon class action settlement from $2.75M to $2M. On the other hand, the court applied the Bluetooth precedent incorrectly: that $750,000 will revert to HP, rather than the class, and the judge failed to find that the kicker provision provided any benefit to the class. And, remarkably, the fact that the class representative opposed the settlement carried no weight.
In re HP Laserjet
- "Attorney fee-only" bankruptcy plans
- Prospective injunctive relief class actions and McNair v. Synapse Group Inc.
- Apple iPhone 4 bumper class action settlement
- Third Circuit argument in Dewey v. Volkswagen
- Dewey v. Volkswagen oral argument tomorrow
- How much is the Bluetooth settlement injunction worth?
- CCAF Seventh Circuit briefing on derivative shareholder suit standards
- Around the web, March 13
- Day v. Persels & Associates
- Bad typography evidence of bad faith?
- Apple class actions
- 0.1% claim rate in "successful" class action
- Cobell v. Salazar oral argument in DC Circuit
- Asbestos litigation and search-engine optimization
- Herzfeld & Rubin, Volkswagen, and Stockholm Syndrome