Thomas Brown, who has shortened breath, sued Union Carbide, claiming he came down with asbestosis from exposure to drilling mud, but his own physicians denied it. Nor did he have any evidence of lost wages. Never mind, said a Smith County, Mississippi, jury after some fishy rulings by Judge Eddie Bowen: they compounded a ridiculous $11 million for future medical expense and $11 million for fear of future disease with an even more ridiculous $300 million in punitive damages. Now Union Carbide seeks to throw out the verdict on the grounds that the judge failed to disclose, much less recuse himself over, the fact that the judge's father sued and settled an asbestos case against Union Carbide. Nearly 9% of the adult population of Smith County has filed asbestos claims, but the motion to move the trial out of county was denied. [Fisher @ Forbes; Clarion Ledger; LNL; ILR]
$322M verdict for phantom asbestosis
Related Entries:
- Judge orders end to trial reservation system in Madison County asbestos docket
- More on 2006 Louisiana environmental law's jackpot justice
- How much is the Bluetooth settlement injunction worth?
- Around the web, March 13
- The problem of the special master
- PR efforts in atrazine litigation
- Around the web, February 21
- Deep pocket files: Scott Simon and Harding Pharmacy
- Asbestos litigation and search-engine optimization
- "Porsche girl" lawsuit update
- CJD still lying about hot coffee
- California rejects tertiary asbestos liability in O'Neill v. Crane
- "Missouri lawyers weigh in on class action concerns"
- Madison County's controversial asbestos litigation system under fire yet again
- Around the web, December 15
![]() |
Rafael Mangual Project Manager, Legal Policy rmangual@manhattan-institute.org |
![]() |
Communications Manhattan Institute communications@manhattan-institute.org |