...at least if you're planning to use a "Prozac defense" or "Zoloft defense" and argue that the pills you were taking ineluctably drove you to commit your crime. In the South Carolina case of Christopher Pittman, charged with first-degree murder after shooting his grandparents, plaintiff's lawyers Arnold ("Andy") Vickery of Houston and Karen Barth Menzies of Los Angeles, who've been suing antidepressant makers for years, stepped forward to provide Pittman with criminal representation on his Zoloft defense. They're asking the court to order Pfizer, the drug's maker, to release reams of documents which they say would be helpful to client Pittman's case. And not just helpful to him alone, either, it might occur to a cynic. The New York Times's Barry Meier covered the case last month. Update Mar. 11, 2005: jury convicts Pittman.
Plaintiff's bar: let us handle your criminal defense
Related Entries:
- Reflection on the criminal law scholarship of William Stuntz
- Felon voting, Santorum, and Romney
- New Podcast: James Copland and Timothy O'Toole discuss overcriminalization concerns raised by the 'Clean Up Government Act'
- 'Clean Up Government Act' sparks overcriminalization concerns
- The expense of the death penalty
- New 'Global Economic Crime Survey' shows decline in bribery and money laundering
- Examining 'honest services' post-Skilling
- Promise of FCPA guidance prompts inquiries
- New Database Tracks FCPA Enforcement
- Los Angeles Faces Potential Early Release of Thousands of Inmates
- SEC Reports First FCPA Enforcement Statistics
- NACDL Releases Blueprint for Grand Jury Reform
- Around the web, October 31
- "As Federal Crime List Grows, Threshold of Guilt Declines"
- Kerr on Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
![]() |
| Isaac Gorodetski Project Manager, Center for Legal Policy at the Manhattan Institute igorodetski@manhattan-institute.org |
![]() |
| Laura Eyi Press Officer, Manhattan Institute leyi@manhattan-institute.org |



