Plaintiffs asked for $6 billion; WR Grace said the asbestos claims were worth only $500 million because of extensive fraud. According to Bloomberg, the parties settle for "$1.8 billion," though this amount consists of in-the-money options and payments over 15 years beginning in 2019, so is substantially inflated in present value--depending on the discount rate one uses, the total is more like $600 to $900 million. I haven't yet explored the filing in detail to see what audit protections the settlement will have: will the plaintiffs' lawyers have a blank check to divvy up funds, or will allocations be decided by a neutral administrator as in the Vioxx settlement? And, alas, the settlement means we won't get a federal judge making authoritative pronouncements on the extent of fraud by the asbestos plaintiffs' bar, though the fact that the plaintiffs are settling for less than a quarter on the dollar (well under $1.3 billion of the $5.5 billion in dispute) is telling. More: the 8-K filing; Reuters; Thomson/CNN/Money.
BREAKING: WR Grace settles
Related Entries:
- Judge orders end to trial reservation system in Madison County asbestos docket
- California rejects tertiary asbestos liability in O'Neill v. Crane
- Madison County's controversial asbestos litigation system under fire yet again
- SEC files to appeal Judge Rakoff's rejection of Citi settlement
- Trask on Prakash
- Federal district court rejects Citigroup-SEC settlement, sets trial date
- Greg Conko discusses the FDA's ban on off-label promotion
- Wal-Mart Settlement Offer: Potentially Pocket Change for Class Member Participants
- SEC and Citigroup Anxiously Await Ruling
- Gryphon on Prakash on Vioxx
- Congressional hearing on asbestos fraud
- Around the web, September 9
- Judge orders lawyers to mandatory Labor-Day weekend seminar
- Around the web, August 22
- Zero for Ground Zero worker
![]() |
| Isaac Gorodetski Project Manager, Center for Legal Policy at the Manhattan Institute igorodetski@manhattan-institute.org |
![]() |
| Laura Eyi Press Officer, Manhattan Institute leyi@manhattan-institute.org |



