Subscribe Subscribe   Find us on Twitter Follow POL on Twitter  



Chutzpah files: Madison County judge-shopping

Illinois, like some other states, allows parties to request a single change of judge as of right. That statute is questionable enough public policy as it is, but Madison County judges had interpreted the rule to permit class action plaintiffs to obtain automatic changes for each plaintiff in the case—thus effectively permitting a class action attorney to pick his judge. Madison County Chief Judge Ann Callis has changed the rule so that it limits substitution of judge to only one time as a right, and the Korein Tillery law firm is now challenging that rule's constitutionality, which could delay its implementation for a couple of years if they get the right judges to hear the case. (Steve Gonzalez, "'Judge shopping' rule challenged by Tillery firm", Madison County Record, Aug. 31; Brian Brueggeman, "Law firm set to challenge court ban on automatic judge change", Belleville News-Democrat, Sep. 1). (Cross-posted at Overlawyered.)



Rafael Mangual
Project Manager,
Legal Policy

Katherine Lazarski
Manhattan Institute


Published by the Manhattan Institute

The Manhattan Insitute's Center for Legal Policy.